{
  "version": "V20.8.1",
  "generatedAt": "2026-08-06",
  "scope": "Premières 125 mesures du Plan de Rupture",
  "warning": "Qualification citoyenne initiale à expertiser; ne constitue pas un avis juridique.",
  "items": [
    {
      "measure_id": "1.01",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Réduction de l'Assemblée nationale de 577 à 125 députés, un par département",
      "title_en": "Reduce the National Assembly from 577 to 125 members, at least one per department",
      "effect_source": "432 à 467 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique; loi électorale",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Premier ministre / Justice",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 24, 25 et 89",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Mandat — phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "432 to 467 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act; electoral law",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Prime Minister / Justice Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 24, 25 and 89",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Term of office — constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.02",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Réduction du Sénat de 348 à 125 sénateurs",
      "title_en": "Reduce the Senate from 348 to 125 senators",
      "effect_source": "232 à 250 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique; loi électorale",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Premier ministre / Justice",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 24, 25 et 89",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Sénat; Assemblée nationale; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Mandat — phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "232 to 250 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act; electoral law",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Prime Minister / Justice Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 24, 25 and 89",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Senate; National Assembly; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Term of office — constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.03",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Réduction du gouvernement à 9 ministères de plein exercice, suppression des ministres délégués",
      "title_en": "Reduce the government to nine full ministries and abolish delegated ministers",
      "effect_source": "90 à 180 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets d’attributions; décisions budgétaires",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Premier ministre",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 8, 20 et 21",
      "consultations": "Secrétariat général du Gouvernement; arbitrages interministériels",
      "implementation_phase": "100 premiers jours",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "90 to 180 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "ministerial portfolio decrees; budget decisions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Prime Minister",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 8, 20 and 21",
      "consultations_en": "General Secretariat of the Government; interministerial decisions",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First 100 days",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.04",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Obligation de présence parlementaire avec sanctions financières automatiques",
      "title_en": "Mandatory parliamentary attendance with automatic financial penalties",
      "effect_source": "150 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi organique + règlements des assemblées",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décisions des bureaux; contrôle constitutionnel",
      "lead_authority": "Parlement",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 25; ordonnances organiques; règlements",
      "consultations": "Bureaux des assemblées; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "150 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Organic Act and standing orders of the Houses",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decisions of the parliamentary bureaux; constitutional review",
      "lead_authority_en": "Parliament",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 25; organic ordinances; standing orders or regulations",
      "consultations_en": "parliamentary bureaux of the Houses; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.05",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Division par deux du crédit collaborateurs parlementaires",
      "title_en": "Halve parliamentary staff allowances",
      "effect_source": "85 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décisions parlementaires internes",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois de finances / dotations des assemblées",
      "lead_authority": "Assemblée nationale / Sénat",
      "legal_anchor": "Autonomie financière des assemblées; règlements et décisions des bureaux",
      "consultations": "Questeurs; bureaux; commissions des finances",
      "implementation_phase": "100 premiers jours",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "85 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Internal parliamentary decisions",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Finance Acts and appropriations of the Houses",
      "lead_authority_en": "National Assembly / Senate",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: financial autonomy of the Houses; standing orders or regulations and decisions of the parliamentary bureaux",
      "consultations_en": "quaestors; parliamentary bureaux; finance committees",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First 100 days",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.06",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Suppression des 1 758 conseillers régionaux",
      "title_en": "Abolish the 1,758 regional councillor seats",
      "effect_source": "350 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Code électoral; CGCT; coordination constitutionnelle si suppression des régions",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Collectivités territoriales",
      "legal_anchor": "Code électoral; CGCT; Constitution art. 72 selon périmètre",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; associations d’élus; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase institutionnelle",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "350 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Electoral Code; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); constitutional coordination if the regional tier is abolished",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Local Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Electoral Code; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); Constitution art. 72 depending on scope",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; associations of elected representatives; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Institutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.07",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Réduction de 50 pour cent des conseillers départementaux",
      "title_en": "Reduce departmental councillors by 50 percent",
      "effect_source": "180 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Code électoral; CGCT",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Collectivités territoriales",
      "legal_anchor": "Code électoral; CGCT",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; associations d’élus; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "180 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Electoral Code; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT)",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Local Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Electoral Code; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT)",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; associations of elected representatives; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.08",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Limitation des cabinets ministériels à 10 membres",
      "title_en": "Limit ministerial cabinets to ten members",
      "effect_source": "120 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret",
      "secondary_instruments": "Circulaire d’application; plafond d’emplois",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Décret relatif aux cabinets ministériels; LOLF",
      "consultations": "SGG; Budget; ministères",
      "implementation_phase": "100 premiers jours",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "120 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "implementation circular; employment ceiling",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: decree governing ministerial private offices; Organic Budget Act (LOLF)",
      "consultations_en": "General Secretariat of the Government; Budget; ministries",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First 100 days",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.09",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Interdiction stricte du cumul des mandats exécutifs locaux",
      "title_en": "Strict ban on holding multiple local executive mandates",
      "effect_source": "200 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi organique + loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Code électoral; CGCT",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Justice",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 25; code électoral; CGCT",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "200 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Organic Act and Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Electoral Code; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT)",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Justice Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 25; code électoral; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT)",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.10",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Plafonnement des indemnités cumulées à 150 pour cent du mandat principal",
      "title_en": "Cap combined allowances at 150 percent of the main mandate",
      "effect_source": "80 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire / organique",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets et règlements des assemblées",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Parlement / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "CGCT; code électoral; règles parlementaires",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; bureaux des assemblées",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "80 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees and standing orders or regulations of the assemblées",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Parliament / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); code électoral; règles parlementaires",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; parliamentary bureaux of the Houses",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.11",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Réduction d'environ 30 pour cent des conseillers municipaux",
      "title_en": "Reduce municipal councillors by about 30 percent",
      "effect_source": "250 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Code électoral; CGCT",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Collectivités territoriales",
      "legal_anchor": "Code électoral; CGCT",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; associations d’élus; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "250 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Electoral Code; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT)",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Local Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Electoral Code; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT)",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; associations of elected representatives; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.12",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Suppression du Conseil économique, social et environnemental national",
      "title_en": "Abolish the national Economic, Social and Environmental Council",
      "effect_source": "36 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique d’abrogation / coordination",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Premier ministre / Justice",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution titre XI, art. 69 à 71; art. 89",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement réuni selon procédure; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "36 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "organic repeal and coordination Act",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Prime Minister / Justice Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution titre XI, art. 69 à 71; art. 89",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament réuni depending on procédure; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.13",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Suppression des 13 conseils économiques, sociaux et environnementaux régionaux",
      "title_en": "Abolish the 13 regional economic, social and environmental councils",
      "effect_source": "75 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "CGCT; dispositions transitoires",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Collectivités territoriales",
      "legal_anchor": "CGCT",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; régions; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "75 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); transitional provisions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Local Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Local Authorities Code (CGCT)",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; régions; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.14",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Transparence totale des rémunérations publiques sur plateforme dédiée",
      "title_en": "Full transparency of public remuneration on a dedicated platform",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décret; référentiel de données; règles d’anonymisation",
      "lead_authority": "Transformation publique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "RGPD; loi Informatique et libertés; code général de la fonction publique",
      "consultations": "CNIL; Conseil d’État; organisations syndicales",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Décret; data standard; anonymisation rules",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transformation publique / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: GDPR; French Data Protection Act; code général of the fonction publique",
      "consultations_en": "CNIL; Conseil d’État; trade unions",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.15",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Plafonnement des rémunérations publiques à 6 fois le salaire minimum brut",
      "title_en": "Cap public remuneration at six times the gross minimum wage",
      "effect_source": "320 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + lois financières",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets statutaires; contrats d’objectifs",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Fonction publique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général de la fonction publique; principes d’égalité et sécurité juridique",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; organisations syndicales; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "320 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and finance legislation",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "staff-regulation decrees; contrats d’objectifs",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Civil Service",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Civil Service Code; principes d’égalité and sécurité juridique",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; trade unions; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.16",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Suppression de la protection rapprochée à vie des anciens présidents",
      "title_en": "End lifetime close protection for former presidents",
      "effect_source": "5 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décision réglementaire / instruction",
      "secondary_instruments": "Évaluation individuelle de sécurité",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Présidence",
      "legal_anchor": "Pouvoir de police; doctrine de protection des personnalités",
      "consultations": "Services de sécurité; contrôle de proportionnalité",
      "implementation_phase": "100 premiers jours",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "5 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Regulatory decision or administrative instruction",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "individual security assessment",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Presidency",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Pouvoir of police; doctrine of protection of the personnalités",
      "consultations_en": "Services of sécurité; contrôle of proportionnalité",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First 100 days",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.17",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Réduction du budget de la présidence et transparence intégrale",
      "title_en": "Reduce the presidential budget and ensure full transparency",
      "effect_source": "30 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Règles internes; publication de données",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Budget / Parlement",
      "legal_anchor": "LOLF; mission Pouvoirs publics",
      "consultations": "Commissions des finances; Cour des comptes",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget initial",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "30 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "internal rules; data publication",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Budget Ministry / Parliament",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Organic Budget Act (LOLF); mission Pouvoirs publics",
      "consultations_en": "Commissions of the finances; Cour of the comptes",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Initial budget",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.18",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Suppression des restaurants et buvettes parlementaires subventionnés",
      "title_en": "End subsidies for parliamentary restaurants and bars",
      "effect_source": "12 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décisions parlementaires internes",
      "secondary_instruments": "Marchés; tarification; dotations",
      "lead_authority": "Assemblée nationale / Sénat",
      "legal_anchor": "Autonomie des assemblées; décisions de questure",
      "consultations": "Bureaux; questeurs",
      "implementation_phase": "100 premiers jours",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "12 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Internal parliamentary decisions",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "procurement; pricing; appropriations",
      "lead_authority_en": "National Assembly / Senate",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Autonomie of the assemblées; décisions of questure",
      "consultations_en": "Bureaux; quaestors",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First 100 days",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.19",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Suppression des avantages en nature non justifiés par la sécurité",
      "title_en": "Remove benefits in kind not justified by security",
      "effect_source": "180 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Paquet mixte",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi; décret; décisions internes selon bénéficiaires",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Fonction publique / Parlement",
      "legal_anchor": "CGFP; règles indemnitaires; règlements des assemblées",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; organisations syndicales; bureaux",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "180 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legislative and regulatory package",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Loi; décret; décisions internes depending on the beneficiaries",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Civil Service / Parliament",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: CGFP; règles indemnitaires; standing orders or regulations of the assemblées",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; trade unions; parliamentary bureaux",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "1.20",
      "category": 1,
      "title_fr": "Harmonisation et plafonnement des régimes indemnitaires de la haute fonction publique",
      "title_en": "Harmonise and cap senior civil-service allowance schemes",
      "effect_source": "450 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret + loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets statutaires; lignes directrices de gestion",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général de la fonction publique; textes indemnitaires",
      "consultations": "Conseil commun de la fonction publique; Conseil d’État",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "450 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Decree and Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "staff-regulation decrees; management guidelines",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Civil Service Code; textes indemnitaires",
      "consultations_en": "Common Council of the Civil Service; Conseil d’État",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.01",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Suppression complète de l'échelon administratif régional",
      "title_en": "Completely abolish the regional administrative tier",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé en fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle + loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "CGCT; code électoral; transferts de compétences",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Collectivités territoriales / Premier ministre",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 72; CGCT; code électoral",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; collectivités; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle et 24 mois",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment and Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); code électoral; transfers of powers",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Local Government / Prime Minister",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 72; General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); code électoral",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; local authorities; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase et 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.02",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Suppression des intercommunalités, retour à la souveraineté communale",
      "title_en": "Abolish inter-municipal structures and restore municipal sovereignty",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé en fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "CGCT; lois financières; conventions de transfert",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Collectivités territoriales",
      "legal_anchor": "CGCT; principes de libre administration",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; communes; associations d’élus; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); lois financières; transfer agreements",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Local Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Local Authorities Code (CGCT); principes of libre administration",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; municipalities; associations of elected representatives; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.03",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Transition sans licenciement sec, mobilité accompagnée des 128 000 agents",
      "title_en": "Transition without forced redundancies, supported mobility for 128,000 staff",
      "effect_source": "Investissement",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets statutaires; accords collectifs; budget",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général de la fonction publique",
      "consultations": "Conseil commun de la fonction publique; organisations syndicales",
      "implementation_phase": "Mandat — volet social",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "staff-regulation decrees; collective agreements; budget",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Civil Service Code",
      "consultations_en": "Common Council of the Civil Service; trade unions",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Term of office — social component",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.04",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Mission interministérielle de nettoyage législatif sur 5 ans",
      "title_en": "Five-year interministerial legislative clean-up mission",
      "effect_source": "8 à 12 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret du Premier ministre",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois de simplification; ordonnances; rapports annuels",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / SGG",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 37 et 38; guide de légistique",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État selon textes; Parlement pour habilitations",
      "implementation_phase": "100 premiers jours puis 5 ans",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "8 to 12 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Prime Ministerial decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Lois of simplification; ordinances; annual reports",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / General Secretariat of the Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 37 and 38; guide of légistique",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État depending on textes; Parliament for habilitations",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First 100 days then 5 years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.05",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Règle « une norme créée, deux supprimées » constitutionnalisée",
      "title_en": "Constitutionalise a one-in, two-out rule for regulations",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique / mécanisme de contrôle",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Premier ministre / Justice",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 89",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act / oversight mechanism",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Prime Minister / Justice Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 89",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.06",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Réduction du nombre de codes juridiques de 69 à 20 maximum",
      "title_en": "Reduce the number of legal codes from 69 to no more than 20",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi d’habilitation + ordonnances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets de codification; lois de ratification",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Justice / SGG",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 38; principes de codification",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; commissions supérieures de codification; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "5 ans",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Enabling Act and ordinances",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "codification decrees; ratification Acts",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Justice Ministry / General Secretariat of the Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 38; principes of codification",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; commissions supérieures of codification; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.07",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Digitalisation complète de l'administration sur 5 ans",
      "title_en": "Fully digitise the administration over five years",
      "effect_source": "10 à 15 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois financières; décrets; marchés; référentiels numériques",
      "lead_authority": "Transformation publique / Numérique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "RGPD; loi Informatique et libertés; code commande publique",
      "consultations": "CNIL; Conseil d’État; organisations syndicales",
      "implementation_phase": "5 ans",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "10 to 15 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Lois financières; decrees; marchés; digital standards",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transformation publique / Digital Affairs / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: GDPR; French Data Protection Act; Public Procurement Code",
      "consultations_en": "CNIL; Conseil d’État; trade unions",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.08",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Guichet unique départemental pour toutes les démarches",
      "title_en": "Create a single departmental access point for all procedures",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + décret",
      "secondary_instruments": "Conventions; organisation territoriale; systèmes d’information",
      "lead_authority": "Intérieur / Transformation publique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code des relations entre le public et l’administration; décrets territoriaux",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; préfets; collectivités; CNIL",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 30 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Conventions; territorial organisation; information systems",
      "lead_authority_en": "Interior Ministry / Transformation publique",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration; decrees territoriaux",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; prefects; local authorities; CNIL",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 30 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.09",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Non-remplacement de 30 à 50 pour cent des départs naturels",
      "title_en": "Do not replace 30 to 50 percent of natural departures",
      "effect_source": "Économie budgétaire",
      "primary_instrument": "Lois de finances / plafonds d’emplois",
      "secondary_instruments": "Plans de gestion ministériels; rapports annuels",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Fonction publique",
      "legal_anchor": "LOLF; plafonds d’emplois; CGFP",
      "consultations": "Parlement; organisations syndicales; comités sociaux",
      "implementation_phase": "Budgets annuels sur 5 ans",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Économie budgétaire",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Acts and employment ceilings",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "ministerial management plans; annual reports",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Civil Service",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Organic Budget Act (LOLF); plafonds d’emplois; CGFP",
      "consultations_en": "Parliament; trade unions; social committees",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budgets over five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.10",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Mobilité interne accompagnée vers les services prioritaires",
      "title_en": "Supported internal mobility towards priority services",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel",
      "primary_instrument": "Décrets statutaires + accords collectifs",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi de programmation; lignes directrices de gestion",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / ministères",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général de la fonction publique",
      "consultations": "Organisations syndicales; conseils supérieurs",
      "implementation_phase": "Mandat — continu",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Staff-regulation decrees and collective agreements",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "programming Act; management guidelines",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / ministères",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Civil Service Code",
      "consultations_en": "Organisations syndicales; higher councils",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Term of office — continuous",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.11",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Rupture conventionnelle revalorisée à un mois de salaire par année",
      "title_en": "Raise mutually agreed severance to one month of salary per year",
      "effect_source": "Investissement",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décret d’indemnisation; plafonds et contrôles",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général de la fonction publique",
      "consultations": "Conseil commun; Conseil d’État; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "compensation decree; ceilings and controls",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: General Civil Service Code",
      "consultations_en": "Common Council; Conseil d’État; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.12",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Cessation progressive d'activité pour les seniors de 58 à 62 ans",
      "title_en": "Progressive reduction of activity for staff aged 58 to 62",
      "effect_source": "Investissement",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire / programmation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets statutaires; financement",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "CGFP; droit des pensions; égalité de traitement",
      "consultations": "Conseil commun; caisses; Conseil d’État",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "staff-regulation decrees; financement",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: CGFP; droit of the pensions; égalité of traitement",
      "consultations_en": "Common Council; social-security funds; Conseil d’État",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "2.13",
      "category": 2,
      "title_fr": "Formation diplômante de 400 000 agents à l'intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "Degree-awarding AI training for 400,000 public employees",
      "effect_source": "Investissement",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation + budget",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; référentiel de compétences; marchés de formation",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / Numérique / Éducation",
      "legal_anchor": "CGFP; code de l’éducation; commande publique",
      "consultations": "Organisations syndicales; France compétences selon dispositif",
      "implementation_phase": "5 ans",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act and budget measures",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; skills framework; training contracts",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / Digital Affairs / Education Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: CGFP; Education Code; commande publique",
      "consultations_en": "Organisations syndicales; France compétences depending on dispositif",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.01",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie A, audit du train de vie des 552 entités préservées",
      "title_en": "Category A: audit the operating costs of 552 preserved entities",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé en fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret / circulaire interministérielle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Contrats d’objectifs; audits IGF/inspections",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "LOLF; tutelles des opérateurs",
      "consultations": "Ministères de tutelle; corps de contrôle",
      "implementation_phase": "100 premiers jours puis 18 mois",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Decree or interministerial circular",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Contrats d’objectifs; audits IGF/inspections",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Organic Budget Act (LOLF); tutelles of the opérateurs",
      "consultations_en": "Ministères of tutelle; corps of contrôle",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First 100 days then 18 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.02",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie A, plafonnement des rémunérations dirigeantes",
      "title_en": "Category A: cap executive remuneration",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé en fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances + décret",
      "secondary_instruments": "Contrats; décisions de tutelle",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Fonction publique",
      "legal_anchor": "LOLF; CGFP; textes propres aux opérateurs",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; tutelles; instances sociales",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act and decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Contrats; décisions of tutelle",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Civil Service",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Organic Budget Act (LOLF); CGFP; textes propres to the opérateurs",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; supervising ministries; staff-representation bodies",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.03",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie A, mutualisation interministérielle des fonctions support",
      "title_en": "Category A: interministerial pooling of support functions",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé en fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi d’habilitation + ordonnances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; conventions de services partagés",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Budget / Transformation publique",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 38; LOLF; statuts des opérateurs",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; tutelles; instances sociales",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Enabling Act and ordinances",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; conventions of services partagés",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Budget Ministry / Transformation publique",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 38; Organic Budget Act (LOLF); statuts of the opérateurs",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; supervising ministries; staff-representation bodies",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.04",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie A, déploiement systématique de l'intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "Category A: systematic deployment of artificial intelligence",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé en fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; marchés; référentiels; analyses d’impact IA",
      "lead_authority": "Numérique / Fonction publique / tutelles",
      "legal_anchor": "RGPD; règlement européen IA; commande publique",
      "consultations": "CNIL; autorités sectorielles; organisations syndicales",
      "implementation_phase": "5 ans",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; marchés; référentiels; analyses d’impact IA",
      "lead_authority_en": "Digital Affairs / Civil Service / tutelles",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: GDPR; règlement européen IA; commande publique",
      "consultations_en": "CNIL; autorités sectorielles; trade unions",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.05",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie B, fusion des 35 grappes d'opérateurs",
      "title_en": "Category B: merge 35 clusters of public operators",
      "effect_source": "2,3 à 4,1 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi-cadre + habilitation à légiférer par ordonnances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Ordonnances; lois de ratification; décrets; conventions",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Budget / ministères de tutelle",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 38; statuts propres des entités",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; instances sociales; tutelles",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "2,3 to 4,1 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Framework Act and authority to legislate by ordinance",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "ordinances; ratification Acts; decrees; conventions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Budget Ministry / ministères of tutelle",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 38; statuts propres of the entités",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; staff-representation bodies; supervising ministries",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.06",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie C, réintégration des entités à autonomie injustifiée",
      "title_en": "Category C: reintegrate entities whose autonomy is unjustified",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé en fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Paquet législatif et réglementaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Ordonnances; décrets; arrêtés; transferts budgétaires",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Budget / tutelles",
      "legal_anchor": "Textes constitutifs de chaque entité",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; instances sociales; organismes concernés",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 48 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "ordinances; decrees; arrêtés; transferts budgétaires",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Budget Ministry / tutelles",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Textes constitutifs of chaque entité",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; staff-representation bodies; organismes concernés",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 48 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.07",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, suppression de l'ADEME, financement direct des aides (montant net)",
      "title_en": "Category D: abolish ADEME and finance aid directly (net amount)",
      "effect_source": "150 à 300 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + décret en Conseil d’État",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois financières; arrêtés; conventions de transfert",
      "lead_authority": "Transition écologique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code environnement L.131-3 à L.131-7; R.131-1 à R.131-26-4",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; instances sociales; bénéficiaires; organismes repreneurs",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "150 to 300 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and decree after mandatory Conseil d’État review",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Lois financières; arrêtés; transfer agreements",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transition écologique / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code environnement L.131-3 à L.131-7; R.131-1 à R.131-26-4",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; staff-representation bodies; bénéficiaires; organismes repreneurs",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.08",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, suppression de l'Office français de la biodiversité (montant net)",
      "title_en": "Category D: abolish the French Biodiversity Office (net amount)",
      "effect_source": "180 à 320 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + décret en Conseil d’État",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois financières; arrêtés; conventions; audit des polices",
      "lead_authority": "Transition écologique / Agriculture / Intérieur / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code environnement L.131-8 à L.131-17; R.131-27 à R.131-34-5",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; instances sociales; procureurs/préfets; organismes repreneurs",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 30 mois",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "180 to 320 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and decree after mandatory Conseil d’État review",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Lois financières; arrêtés; conventions; audit of the polices",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transition écologique / Agriculture Ministry / Interior Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code environnement L.131-8 à L.131-17; R.131-27 à R.131-34-5",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; staff-representation bodies; procureurs/prefects; organismes repreneurs",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 30 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.09",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, suppression de l'AFITF (montant net)",
      "title_en": "Category D: abolish AFITF (net amount)",
      "effect_source": "90 à 180 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret en Conseil d’État + lois financières",
      "secondary_instruments": "Transferts contractuels; programmation infrastructures",
      "lead_authority": "Transports / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Décret constitutif AFITF; textes budgétaires affectant recettes",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; collectivités et concessionnaires concernés",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "90 to 180 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "decree after mandatory Conseil d’État review and decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Transferts contractuels; programmation infrastructures",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transport Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Décret constitutif AFITF; textes budgétaires affectant recettes",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; local authorities and concessionnaires concernés",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.10",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, suppression des agences régionales de santé (montant net)",
      "title_en": "Category D: abolish regional health agencies (net amount)",
      "effect_source": "180 à 350 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + loi de financement de la sécurité sociale",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; transferts personnels/compétences",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Budget / Sécurité sociale",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de la santé publique; lois HPST et textes ultérieurs",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; caisses; conférences territoriales; instances sociales",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "180 to 350 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; transferts personnels/compétences",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Budget Ministry / Social Security",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of the santé publique; lois HPST and textes ultérieurs",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; social-security funds; conférences territoriales; staff-representation bodies",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.11",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, suppression des directions régionales de l'agriculture (montant net)",
      "title_en": "Category D: abolish regional agriculture directorates (net amount)",
      "effect_source": "60 à 120 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret",
      "secondary_instruments": "Arrêtés d’organisation; transferts d’emplois et crédits",
      "lead_authority": "Agriculture / Intérieur / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Décrets relatifs aux services déconcentrés",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État si décret CE; comités sociaux; préfets",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "60 to 120 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Arrêtés d’organisation; transferts d’emplois and crédits",
      "lead_authority_en": "Agriculture Ministry / Interior Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: decrees relatifs to the services déconcentrés",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État if décret CE; social committees; prefects",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.12",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, rationalisation DDT, DREAL et agences de l'eau",
      "title_en": "Category D: rationalise DDT, DREAL and water agencies",
      "effect_source": "400 à 1 200 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Paquet mixte loi + décrets",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois financières; transferts; conventions",
      "lead_authority": "Transition écologique / Intérieur / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code environnement pour agences de l’eau; décrets services déconcentrés",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; comités de bassin; collectivités; instances sociales",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 48 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "400 to 1 200 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Lois financières; transferts; conventions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transition écologique / Interior Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code environnement for agences of l’eau; decrees services déconcentrés",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; comités of bassin; local authorities; staff-representation bodies",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 48 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.13",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, suppression des 316 comités consultatifs marginaux",
      "title_en": "Category D: abolish 316 marginal consultative committees",
      "effect_source": "120 à 240 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de simplification + décrets",
      "secondary_instruments": "Arrêtés d’abrogation; inventaire au JO",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / SGG",
      "legal_anchor": "Texte créateur de chaque instance",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État selon niveau; ministères; partenaires consultés",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "120 to 240 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Arrêtés d’abrogation; inventaire to the JO",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / General Secretariat of the Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Texte créateur of chaque instance",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État depending on niveau; ministries; partenaires consultés",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.14",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Catégorie D, réorganisation de l'Arcom et suppression de ses éventuels doublons",
      "title_en": "Category D: reorganise Arcom and remove any overlapping functions",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé fiche par fiche",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; coordination avec droit européen",
      "lead_authority": "Culture / Numérique / Premier ministre",
      "legal_anchor": "Loi relative à la communication audiovisuelle; statut Arcom",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Arcom; Parlement; Commission européenne selon besoin",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 30 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "Chiffrage détaillé fiche par fiche",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; coordination avec droit européen",
      "lead_authority_en": "Culture Ministry / Digital Affairs / Prime Minister",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Loi relative à the communication audiovisuelle; statut Arcom",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Arcom; Parliament; Commission européenne depending on besoin",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 30 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.15",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Démantèlement de France Télévisions et privatisation par actifs",
      "title_en": "Break up France Télévisions and privatise assets",
      "effect_source": "2,6 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; cessions; droit social; concurrence",
      "lead_authority": "Culture / Budget / Économie",
      "legal_anchor": "Loi communication audiovisuelle; droit des sociétés; droit UE",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Arcom; instances sociales; autorité concurrence; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "36 à 60 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "2,6 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; cessions; droit social; concurrence",
      "lead_authority_en": "Culture Ministry / Budget Ministry / Economy Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Loi communication audiovisuelle; droit of the sociétés; droit UE",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Arcom; staff-representation bodies; autorité concurrence; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "36 to 60 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.16",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Rationalisation forte de Radio France, de 30 à 45 pour cent",
      "title_en": "Strong rationalisation of Radio France by 30 to 45 percent",
      "effect_source": "200 à 300 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Contrat d’objectifs + loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décret / décisions de tutelle; accords sociaux",
      "lead_authority": "Culture / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Loi communication audiovisuelle; contrats d’objectifs et de moyens",
      "consultations": "Arcom; instances sociales; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 48 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "200 to 300 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Décret / décisions of tutelle; accords sociaux",
      "lead_authority_en": "Culture Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Loi communication audiovisuelle; contrats d’objectifs and of moyens",
      "consultations_en": "Arcom; staff-representation bodies; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 48 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.17",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Suppression totale des aides à la presse publique",
      "title_en": "Abolish all public press subsidies",
      "effect_source": "320 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances + décrets d’abrogation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Règles transitoires; contrôle aides d’État",
      "lead_authority": "Culture / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Textes budgétaires et décrets relatifs aux aides à la presse",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Commission européenne selon dispositifs",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget initial / 12 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.6",
      "effect_source_en": "320 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act and decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Règles transitoires; contrôle aides d’État",
      "lead_authority_en": "Culture Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Textes budgétaires and decrees relatifs to the aides à the presse",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Commission européenne depending on dispositifs",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Initial budget / 12 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "3.18",
      "category": 3,
      "title_fr": "Décompte exhaustif des organismes publics nationaux publié au Journal officiel",
      "title_en": "Publish a complete count of national public bodies in the Official Journal",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — contrôle démocratique",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire ou disposition de loi de simplification",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décret et publication annuelle au Journal officiel",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Budget / SGG",
      "legal_anchor": "Périmètre des organismes publics; obligations de publication",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; administrations productrices",
      "implementation_phase": "12 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — democratic oversight",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Décret and publication annuelle to the Journal officiel",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Budget Ministry / General Secretariat of the Government",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Périmètre of the organismes publics; obligations of publication",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; administrations productrices",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.01",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Doublement des moyens budgétaires de la justice sur 5 ans",
      "title_en": "Double justice funding over five years",
      "effect_source": "Investissement",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation + lois de finances annuelles",
      "secondary_instruments": "Plafonds d’emplois; programmation immobilière",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de l’organisation judiciaire; lois financières",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil supérieur de la magistrature selon mesures",
      "implementation_phase": "5 ans",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Plafonds d’emplois; programmation immobilière",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of l’organisation judiciaire; lois financières",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Conseil supérieur of the magistrature depending on mesures",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.02",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Déploiement de l'intelligence artificielle dans les 164 tribunaux",
      "title_en": "Deploy artificial intelligence in 164 courts",
      "effect_source": "1,2 milliard d’euros par an de gains de productivité estimés",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation + marchés publics",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; gouvernance des données; sécurité",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Codes de procédure; droit des données; règlement européen IA",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; magistrats; greffes; ANSSI",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 60 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "1,2 billion euros per year de gains de productivité estimés",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; gouvernance of the données; sécurité",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Codes of procédure; droit of the données; règlement européen IA",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; magistrats; greffes; ANSSI",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 60 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.03",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Pré-instruction automatisée des dossiers simples",
      "title_en": "Automated pre-processing of simple cases",
      "effect_source": "800 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire ou décret selon effet juridique",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets de procédure; marchés; garanties humaines",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Codes de procédure; droit au recours; données personnelles",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; professions judiciaires",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 48 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "800 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees of procédure; marchés; garanties humaines",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Codes of procédure; droit to the recours; données personnelles",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; professions judiciaires",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 48 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.04",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Recherche de jurisprudence assistée par intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "AI-assisted case-law research",
      "effect_source": "150 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décision administrative + marchés publics",
      "secondary_instruments": "Cadre déontologique; sécurité; licences",
      "lead_authority": "Justice",
      "legal_anchor": "Organisation judiciaire; bases de jurisprudence; droit des données",
      "consultations": "CNIL; magistrats; greffes; éditeurs juridiques selon marché",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "150 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Cadre déontologique; sécurité; licences",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Organisation judiciaire; bases of jurisprudence; droit of the données",
      "consultations_en": "CNIL; magistrats; greffes; éditeurs juridiques depending on marché",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.05",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Analyse de cohérence des décisions par échantillonnage",
      "title_en": "Sample-based consistency analysis of decisions",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — contrôle démocratique",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ou décret selon données et effets",
      "secondary_instruments": "Protocole statistique; anonymisation",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / CNIL",
      "legal_anchor": "Secret des délibérés; données judiciaires; statistiques publiques",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Conseil supérieur de la magistrature",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — democratic oversight",
      "primary_instrument_en": "decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Protocole statistique; anonymisation",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / CNIL",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Secret of the délibérés; données judiciaires; statistiques publiques",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Conseil supérieur of the magistrature",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.06",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Déjudiciarisation des litiges fiscaux simples",
      "title_en": "Remove simple tax disputes from courts",
      "effect_source": "2 à 4 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances ou loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets de procédure; médiation; recours",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Livre des procédures fiscales; juridictions administratives",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Conseil national des barreaux; médiateurs; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "2 to 4 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act or Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees of procédure; médiation; recours",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Livre of the procédures fiscales; juridictions administratives",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Conseil national of the barreaux; médiateurs; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.07",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Réduction du délai moyen de jugement civil à 6 mois",
      "title_en": "Reduce average civil judgment time to six months",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — mesure normative",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets de procédure; indicateurs publics",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de procédure civile; organisation judiciaire",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; magistrats; greffes; avocats",
      "implementation_phase": "5 ans",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — regulatory measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees of procédure; indicateurs publics",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of procédure civile; organisation judiciaire",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; magistrats; greffes; avocats",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.08",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Création de 5 000 postes nets de magistrats et greffiers par redéploiement",
      "title_en": "Create 5,000 net judge and clerk positions through redeployment",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Lois de finances + loi de programmation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Schémas d’emplois; concours; mobilité",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Fonction publique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Plafonds d’emplois; statuts magistrats et greffes",
      "consultations": "Parlement; CSM; comités sociaux; écoles de formation",
      "implementation_phase": "3 à 5 ans",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Schémas d’emplois; concours; mobilité",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Civil Service / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Plafonds d’emplois; statuts magistrats and greffes",
      "consultations_en": "Parliament; CSM; social committees; écoles of formation",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Three to five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.09",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Intervention humaine obligatoire pour toute décision défavorable",
      "title_en": "Mandatory human review for every adverse decision",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — garantie juridique",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; procédure de recours; audit algorithmique",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "RGPD art. 22; code relations public-administration; règlement IA",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Défenseur des droits",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — legal safeguard",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; procédure of recours; audit algorithmique",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: GDPR art. 22; code relations public-administration; règlement IA",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Défenseur of the droits",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "4.10",
      "category": 4,
      "title_fr": "Traçabilité totale des décisions assistées, archivage 10 ans",
      "title_en": "Full traceability of assisted decisions with ten-year retention",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — contrôle démocratique",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire ou décret en Conseil d’État",
      "secondary_instruments": "Référentiel d’archivage; cybersécurité",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Culture-Archives / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code patrimoine; données judiciaires; sécurité des systèmes",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Archives de France; ANSSI",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — democratic oversight",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and decree after mandatory Conseil d’État review and decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Référentiel d’archivage; cybersécurité",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Culture Ministry-Archives / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code patrimoine; données judiciaires; sécurité of the systèmes",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Archives of France; ANSSI",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.01",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Réduction des effectifs administratifs hospitaliers, augmentation des soignants",
      "title_en": "Reduce hospital administrative staff and increase care staff",
      "effect_source": "3,5 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "LFSS + loi ordinaire selon organisation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; dialogue social; budgets hospitaliers",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code santé publique; statut hospitalier; financement établissements",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; instances hospitalières; syndicats; assurance maladie",
      "implementation_phase": "3 à 5 ans",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "3,5 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Social Security Finance Act and Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; dialogue social; budgets hospitaliers",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code santé publique; statut hospitalier; financement établissements",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; instances hospitalières; syndicats; assurance maladie",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Three to five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.02",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Rapport vocal de fin de service par intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "AI-assisted end-of-shift voice report",
      "effect_source": "2,8 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret ou expérimentation encadrée",
      "secondary_instruments": "Marchés; certification; protection données de santé",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code santé publique; hébergement données santé; règlement IA",
      "consultations": "CNIL; HAS; professionnels; représentants personnels",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "2,8 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "procurement; certification; protection données of santé",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code santé publique; hébergement données santé; règlement IA",
      "consultations_en": "CNIL; HAS; professionnels; représentants personnels",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.03",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Reversement des dépassements d'honoraires excessifs",
      "title_en": "Recover excessive extra medical fees",
      "effect_source": "1,2 milliard d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "LFSS ou loi santé",
      "secondary_instruments": "Convention médicale; contrôle assurance maladie",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Sécurité sociale",
      "legal_anchor": "Code sécurité sociale; convention nationale médecins",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; UNCAM; syndicats médicaux; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 30 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "1,2 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Social Security Finance Act or health legislation",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Convention médicale; contrôle assurance maladie",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Social Security",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code sécurité sociale; convention nationale médecins",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; National Union of Health Insurance Funds; medical unions; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 30 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.04",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Déréférencement des plateformes de rendez-vous à plus de 3 mois",
      "title_en": "Delist appointment platforms with waits above three months",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — mesure normative",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décret; critères de mesure; procédure contradictoire",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code santé publique; droit plateformes; concurrence",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Autorité concurrence; CNIL; professionnels",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 30 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — regulatory measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Décret; critères of mesure; procédure contradictoire",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code santé publique; droit plateformes; concurrence",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Autorité concurrence; CNIL; professionnels",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 30 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.05",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Réintégration des agences régionales de santé au ministère (montant net)",
      "title_en": "Reintegrate regional health agencies into the ministry (net amount)",
      "effect_source": "180 à 350 millions d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + LFSS",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; transferts personnels, biens et contrats",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Budget / Intérieur",
      "legal_anchor": "Code santé publique; dispositions relatives aux ARS",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; instances sociales; préfets; assurance maladie",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "180 to 350 million euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Social Security Finance Act and Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; transferts personnels, biens and contrats",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Budget Ministry / Interior Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code santé publique; dispositions relatives to the ARS",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; staff-representation bodies; prefects; assurance maladie",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.06",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Maintien des hébergeurs de données de santé certifiés",
      "title_en": "Maintain certified health-data hosting providers",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — garantie juridique",
      "primary_instrument": "Maintien du cadre légal + ajustements réglementaires",
      "secondary_instruments": "Référentiels de certification et sécurité",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code santé publique; certification HDS; RGPD",
      "consultations": "CNIL; ANSSI; organismes certificateurs",
      "implementation_phase": "Continu",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — legal safeguard",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Référentiels of certification and sécurité",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code santé publique; certification HDS; GDPR",
      "consultations_en": "CNIL; ANSSI; organismes certificateurs",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Continuous",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.07",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Détection précoce des pathologies par intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "Early disease detection using artificial intelligence",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — mesure normative",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi santé / expérimentation",
      "secondary_instruments": "Règlement dispositifs médicaux; marchés; protocoles cliniques",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Recherche / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Règlements UE dispositifs médicaux et IA; code santé publique",
      "consultations": "HAS; ANSM; CNIL; comités éthiques; professionnels",
      "implementation_phase": "3 à 7 ans",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — regulatory measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Règlement dispositifs médicaux; marchés; protocoles cliniques",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Research Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Règlements UE dispositifs médicaux and IA; code santé publique",
      "consultations_en": "HAS; ANSM; CNIL; comités éthiques; professionnels",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Three to seven years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "5.08",
      "category": 5,
      "title_fr": "Plafonnement des dépassements d'honoraires en secteur 2",
      "title_en": "Cap extra fees in sector 2",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — mesure normative",
      "primary_instrument": "LFSS ou loi santé",
      "secondary_instruments": "Convention médicale; décret selon mécanisme",
      "lead_authority": "Santé / Sécurité sociale",
      "legal_anchor": "Code sécurité sociale; convention médecins",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; UNCAM; syndicats médicaux; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — regulatory measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Social Security Finance Act or health legislation",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Convention médicale; décret depending on mécanisme",
      "lead_authority_en": "Health Ministry / Social Security",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code sécurité sociale; convention médecins",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; National Union of Health Insurance Funds; medical unions; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.01",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Plafonnement constitutionnel des prélèvements à 50 pour cent",
      "title_en": "Constitutional cap on compulsory levies at 50 percent",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique de définition; indicateur statistique",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Budget / Parlement",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution; définition des prélèvements obligatoires",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel après adoption",
      "implementation_phase": "24 mois ou plus",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act of définition; indicateur statistique",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Budget Ministry / Parliament",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution; définition of the prélèvements obligatoires",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council après adoption",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 months or more",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.02",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Réduction des charges patronales sur les bas salaires",
      "title_en": "Reduce employer contributions on low wages",
      "effect_source": "Gain pour les ménages — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "LFSS",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets de calcul; compensation financière",
      "lead_authority": "Travail / Sécurité sociale / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code sécurité sociale; règles d’allégement",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; caisses; partenaires sociaux; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Gain for households — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Social Security Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees of calcul; compensation financière",
      "lead_authority_en": "Travail / Social Security / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code sécurité sociale; règles d’allégement",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; social-security funds; partenaires sociaux; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.03",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Relèvement de l'abattement successoral à 300 000 euros par enfant",
      "title_en": "Raise inheritance allowance to €300,000 per child",
      "effect_source": "Gain pour les ménages — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Instructions fiscales; systèmes DGFiP",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Économie",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général des impôts, droits de mutation",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Gain for households — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Instructions fiscales; systèmes DGFiP",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Economy Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général of the impôts, droits of mutation",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.04",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Exonération des plus-values immobilières après 10 ans",
      "title_en": "Exempt real-estate capital gains after ten years",
      "effect_source": "Gain pour les ménages — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décret ou doctrine fiscale",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Logement",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général des impôts, plus-values immobilières",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; notaires",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Gain for households — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Décret or doctrine fiscale",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Logement",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général of the impôts, plus-values immobilières",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; notaires",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.05",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Étalement de la taxe d'aménagement sur 15 ans",
      "title_en": "Spread development tax over fifteen years",
      "effect_source": "Gain pour les ménages — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances ou loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; systèmes collectivités et DGFiP",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Collectivités / Logement",
      "legal_anchor": "Code urbanisme et code impositions biens-services",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNEN; collectivités; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "Gain for households — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act or Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; systèmes collectivités and DGFiP",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Collectivités / Logement",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code urbanisme and code impositions biens-services",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; National Council for the Evaluation of Standards; local authorities; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.06",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Suppression du crédit impôt recherche pour les grandes entreprises",
      "title_en": "Abolish the research tax credit for large companies",
      "effect_source": "5,5 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Dispositions transitoires; contrôle aides d’État",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Recherche / Économie",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général des impôts, crédit impôt recherche",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; entreprises; Commission européenne selon besoin",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.7.9",
      "effect_source_en": "5,5 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Dispositions transitoires; contrôle aides d’État",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Research Ministry / Economy Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général of the impôts, crédit impôt recherche",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; entreprises; Commission européenne depending on besoin",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.07",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Réforme du crédit impôt recherche pour les PME et ETI",
      "title_en": "Reform the research tax credit for SMEs and mid-sized companies",
      "effect_source": "2 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; doctrine fiscale; dispositions transitoires",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Recherche / Économie",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général des impôts; crédit impôt recherche; droit européen des aides d’État",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; entreprises; Commission européenne selon le dispositif",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "2 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; doctrine fiscale; transitional provisions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Research Ministry / Economy Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général of the impôts; crédit impôt recherche; droit européen of the aides d’État",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; entreprises; Commission européenne depending on the dispositif",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.08",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Réorientation des économies vers la recherche publique",
      "title_en": "Redirect savings towards public research",
      "effect_source": "Investissement — loi de programmation",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation + lois de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Contrats d’objectifs; répartition des crédits",
      "lead_authority": "Recherche / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de la recherche; lois de finances; contrats des organismes",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; organismes de recherche; établissements",
      "implementation_phase": "Trajectoire pluriannuelle",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment — programming act",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act and annual Finance Acts",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Contrats d’objectifs; répartition of the crédits",
      "lead_authority_en": "Research Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of the recherche; lois of finances; contrats of the organismes",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; organismes of recherche; établissements",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Trajectoire pluriannuelle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.09",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Lutte contre la fraude fiscale par intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "Use artificial intelligence against tax fraud",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé dans la fiche correspondante",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances ou loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; analyse d’impact; marchés; référentiels algorithmiques",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / DGFiP / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Livre des procédures fiscales; RGPD; loi Informatique et Libertés; règlement UE sur l’IA",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Parlement; ANSSI; comité éthique selon usage",
      "implementation_phase": "Expérimentation puis généralisation",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the relevant measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act or Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; analyse d’impact; marchés; référentiels algorithmiques",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / DGFiP / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Livre of the procédures fiscales; GDPR; loi Informatique and Libertés; règlement UE sur l’IA",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Parliament; ANSSI; comité éthique depending on usage",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Pilot followed by scaling",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.10",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Lutte contre la fraude sociale par intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "Use artificial intelligence against social-benefit fraud",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé dans la fiche correspondante",
      "primary_instrument": "LFSS ou loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; conventions des caisses; marchés; analyse d’impact",
      "lead_authority": "Sécurité sociale / Travail / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de la sécurité sociale; RGPD; loi Informatique et Libertés; règlement UE sur l’IA",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; caisses; partenaires sociaux; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Expérimentation puis généralisation",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the relevant measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Social Security Finance Act and Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; conventions of the caisses; marchés; analyse d’impact",
      "lead_authority_en": "Social Security / Travail / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of the sécurité sociale; GDPR; loi Informatique and Libertés; règlement UE sur l’IA",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; social-security funds; partenaires sociaux; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Pilot followed by scaling",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.11",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Toilettage des dépenses fiscales mal ciblées",
      "title_en": "Review and remove poorly targeted tax expenditures",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé dans la fiche correspondante",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Évaluations; dispositions transitoires; doctrine fiscale",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Économie",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général des impôts; annexes des voies et moyens",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; secteurs concernés",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel et revues pluriannuelles",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the relevant measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Évaluations; transitional provisions; doctrine fiscale",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Economy Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général of the impôts; annexes of the voies and moyens",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; secteurs concernés",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Budget annuel et revues pluriannuelles",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.12",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Plafonnement des marges sur les marchés publics à 30 pour cent",
      "title_en": "Cap margins on public contracts at 30 percent",
      "effect_source": "3 à 5 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + réglementation de la commande publique",
      "secondary_instruments": "Méthode de calcul; contrôle; sanctions; clauses types",
      "lead_authority": "Économie / Budget / Achat public",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de la commande publique; directives européennes; droit de la concurrence",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; DAJ; acheteurs; entreprises",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "3 to 5 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Méthode of calcul; contrôle; sanctions; clauses types",
      "lead_authority_en": "Economy Ministry / Budget Ministry / Public Procurement",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Public Procurement Code; directives européennes; droit of the concurrence",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; DAJ; acheteurs; entreprises",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "6.13",
      "category": 6,
      "title_fr": "Suppression de la taxe d’aménagement sur le logement neuf",
      "title_en": "Abolish development tax on new housing",
      "effect_source": "Gain pour les ménages — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Dispositions de compensation; systèmes DGFiP et collectivités",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Logement / Collectivités",
      "legal_anchor": "Code des impositions sur les biens et services; urbanisme; finances locales",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNEN; collectivités; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel avec transition",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Gain for households — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Dispositions of compensation; systèmes DGFiP and collectivités",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Logement / Collectivités",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of the impositions sur les biens and services; urbanisme; finances locales",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; National Council for the Evaluation of Standards; local authorities; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Budget annuel avec tryearsition",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.01",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Renégociation du versement nucléaire universel, dispositif post-ARENH",
      "title_en": "Renegotiate the universal nuclear payment in the post-ARENH framework",
      "effect_source": "3 à 5 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi énergie + négociation européenne",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets tarifaires; décisions de régulation; notification européenne",
      "lead_authority": "Énergie / Économie / Europe",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de l’énergie; droit européen de l’énergie et des aides d’État",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CRE; Commission européenne; acteurs du marché",
      "implementation_phase": "Négociation puis loi",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "3 to 5 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees tarifaires; décisions of régulation; notification européenne",
      "lead_authority_en": "Energy Ministry / Economy Ministry / Europe",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of l’énergie; droit européen of l’énergie and of the aides d’État",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CRE; Commission européenne; acteurs of the marché",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Négociation then loi",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.02",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Renégociation européenne du mécanisme de régulation nucléaire",
      "title_en": "Renegotiate the European nuclear regulation mechanism",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Négociation européenne + loi énergie",
      "secondary_instruments": "Règlements, décisions de régulation et accords européens",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Énergie / Europe",
      "legal_anchor": "Droit de l’Union; code de l’énergie; règles de concurrence",
      "consultations": "Commission européenne; Conseil de l’Union; CRE; Conseil d’État",
      "implementation_phase": "Calendrier européen",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Règlements, décisions of régulation and accords européens",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Energy Ministry / Europe",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Droit of l’Union; code of l’énergie; règles of concurrence",
      "consultations_en": "Commission européenne; Conseil of l’Union; CRE; Conseil d’État",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Calendrier européen",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.03",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Abrogation de la loi de 2017 interdisant l’exploitation des hydrocarbures",
      "title_en": "Repeal the 2017 law banning hydrocarbon production",
      "effect_source": "Recette non chiffrée",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Révision du code minier; décrets environnementaux; dispositions transitoires",
      "lead_authority": "Énergie / Industrie / Environnement",
      "legal_anchor": "Loi du 30 décembre 2017; code minier; code de l’environnement",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNTE; collectivités; Parlement; public selon procédures",
      "implementation_phase": "Première année puis autorisations",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Unquantified revenue",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Révision of the code minier; decrees environnementaux; transitional provisions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Energy Ministry / Industry Ministry / Environnement",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Loi of the 30 décembre 2017; code minier; Environmental Code",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNTE; local authorities; Parliament; public depending on procédures",
      "implementation_phase_en": "First year then autorisations",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.04",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Programme national d’exploration pétrolière et gazière",
      "title_en": "National oil and gas exploration programme",
      "effect_source": "Recette non chiffrée",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation + lois de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Titres miniers; évaluations environnementales; marchés publics",
      "lead_authority": "Énergie / Industrie / Recherche",
      "legal_anchor": "Code minier; code environnement; droit européen; droit maritime selon zones",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNTE; collectivités; public; autorités environnementales",
      "implementation_phase": "3 à 10 ans",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Unquantified revenue",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act and annual Finance Acts",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Titres miniers; évaluations environnementales; marchés publics",
      "lead_authority_en": "Energy Ministry / Industry Ministry / Research Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code minier; code environnement; droit européen; droit maritime depending on zones",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNTE; local authorities; public; autorités environnementales",
      "implementation_phase_en": "3 to 10 years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.05",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Relance du projet Astrid, nucléaire de quatrième génération",
      "title_en": "Restart the ASTRID fourth-generation nuclear programme",
      "effect_source": "Investissement — loi de programmation",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation énergie-recherche",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois de finances; autorisations de sûreté; marchés et partenariats",
      "lead_authority": "Énergie / Recherche / Industrie",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de l’énergie; code environnement; sûreté nucléaire; recherche",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; ASNR; CEA; Parlement; Commission européenne selon financement",
      "implementation_phase": "10 ans ou plus",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment — programming act",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Lois of finances; autorisations of sûreté; marchés and partenariats",
      "lead_authority_en": "Energy Ministry / Research Ministry / Industry Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of l’énergie; code environnement; sûreté nucléaire; recherche",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; ASNR; CEA; Parliament; Commission européenne depending on financement",
      "implementation_phase_en": "10 years or more",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.06",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Préparation à l’exploitation de l’hélium-3 lunaire",
      "title_en": "Prepare for possible lunar helium-3 exploitation",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation recherche-espace",
      "secondary_instruments": "Accords internationaux; programmes CNES/ESA; financement de recherche",
      "lead_authority": "Recherche / Espace / Europe / Affaires étrangères",
      "legal_anchor": "Traité de l’espace; droit international; code de la recherche; accords ESA",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNES; ESA; chercheurs; diplomatie",
      "implementation_phase": "Recherche de long terme",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Accords internationaux; programmes CNES/ESA; financement of recherche",
      "lead_authority_en": "Research Ministry / Espace / Europe / Affaires étrangères",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Traité of l’espace; droit international; code of the recherche; accords ESA",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNES; ESA; chercheurs; diplomatie",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Recherche de long terme",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.07",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Baisse immédiate de 20 centimes par litre sur les taxes carburants",
      "title_en": "Immediate 20-cent-per-litre cut in fuel taxes",
      "effect_source": "Coût de 6 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Tarifs d’accise; compensation; adaptation systèmes fiscaux",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Énergie",
      "legal_anchor": "Code des impositions sur les biens et services; cadre européen de taxation de l’énergie",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Commission européenne selon contraintes",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Cost of 6 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Tarifs d’accise; compensation; adaptation systèmes fiscaux",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Energy Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of the impositions sur les biens and services; cadre européen of taxation of l’énergie",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Commission européenne depending on contraintes",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.08",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Renationalisation des autoroutes à l’échéance des concessions",
      "title_en": "Return motorways to public ownership when concessions expire",
      "effect_source": "2 à 4 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Fin des concessions; création ou désignation de l’opérateur; transferts",
      "lead_authority": "Transports / Budget / Économie",
      "legal_anchor": "Contrats de concession; code de la voirie routière; commande publique",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; concessionnaires; Autorité de régulation des transports; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Selon échéance de chaque concession",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "2 to 4 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Fin of the concessions; création or désignation of l’opérateur; transferts",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transport Ministry / Budget Ministry / Economy Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Contrats of concession; code of the voirie routière; commande publique",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; concessionnaires; Autorité of régulation of the transports; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Selon échéance de chaque concession",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.09",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Taxe sur les surprofits des sociétés concessionnaires d’autoroutes",
      "title_en": "Tax excess profits of motorway concession companies",
      "effect_source": "1,2 milliard d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Définition de l’assiette; contrôle; articulation contractuelle",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Transports",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général des impôts; contrats de concession; principes constitutionnels",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; concessionnaires; régulateur",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "1,2 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Définition of l’assiette; contrôle; articulation contractuelle",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Transport Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général of the impôts; contrats of concession; principes constitutionnels",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; concessionnaires; régulateur",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "7.10",
      "category": 7,
      "title_fr": "Régie nationale des autoroutes après échéance, modèle italien",
      "title_en": "Create a national motorway operator after concessions expire",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Création établissement ou société publique; décret; lois de finances",
      "lead_authority": "Transports / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code voirie routière; droit public économique; règles UE",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; régulateur; Commission européenne selon montage",
      "implementation_phase": "Préparation avant échéances",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Création établissement or société publique; décret; lois of finances",
      "lead_authority_en": "Transport Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code voirie routière; droit public économique; règles UE",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; régulateur; Commission européenne depending on montage",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Préparation avant échéances",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.01",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Renforcement contraignant du label « fait maison »",
      "title_en": "Make the “home-made” label more binding",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décret de définition; contrôles et sanctions",
      "lead_authority": "Commerce / Agriculture / Consommation",
      "legal_anchor": "Code de la consommation; code du tourisme; droit UE information consommateurs",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; professionnels; DGCCRF; Commission européenne selon notification",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Décret of définition; contrôles and sanctions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Commerce / Agriculture Ministry / Consommation",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code of the consommation; code of the tourisme; droit UE information consommateurs",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; professionnels; DGCCRF; Commission européenne depending on notification",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.02",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Cantines publiques à 80 pour cent de produits français en 2030",
      "title_en": "Require public canteens to use 80 percent French products by 2030",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire avec réécriture juridiquement compatible",
      "secondary_instruments": "Commande publique; critères qualité/environnement; suivi annuel",
      "lead_authority": "Agriculture / Collectivités / Éducation",
      "legal_anchor": "Code commande publique; droit UE non-discrimination et libre circulation",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; collectivités; filières agricoles",
      "implementation_phase": "Trajectoire jusqu’en 2030",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Commande publique; critères qualité/environnement; suivi annuel",
      "lead_authority_en": "Agriculture Ministry / Collectivités / Education Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code commande publique; droit UE non-discrimination and libre circulation",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; local authorities; filières agricoles",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Trajectoire jusqu’en 2030",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.03",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Libéralisation de l’autonomie alimentaire citoyenne",
      "title_en": "Liberalise citizen food self-sufficiency",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire multi-codes",
      "secondary_instruments": "Urbanisme; sanitaire; fiscalité; règles locales; expérimentations",
      "lead_authority": "Agriculture / Logement / Santé / Collectivités",
      "legal_anchor": "Codes rural, urbanisme, santé publique, environnement et fiscalité",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; collectivités; agences sanitaires; organisations agricoles",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 48 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Urbanisme; sanitaire; fiscalité; règles locales; expérimentations",
      "lead_authority_en": "Agriculture Ministry / Logement / Health Ministry / Collectivités",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Codes rural, urbanisme, santé publique, environnement and fiscalité",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; local authorities; agences sanitaires; organisations agricoles",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 48 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.04",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Plafonnement des marges sur les marchés publics",
      "title_en": "Cap margins on public contracts",
      "effect_source": "3 à 5 milliards d’euros par an",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire + réglementation commande publique",
      "secondary_instruments": "Méthode comptable; contrôle; sanctions; clauses contractuelles",
      "lead_authority": "Économie / Budget / Achat public",
      "legal_anchor": "Code commande publique; directives UE; droit concurrence",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; acheteurs; entreprises",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "3 to 5 billion euros per year",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Méthode comptable; contrôle; sanctions; clauses contractuelles",
      "lead_authority_en": "Economy Ministry / Budget Ministry / Public Procurement",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code commande publique; directives UE; droit concurrence",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; acheteurs; entreprises",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.05",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Réduction de la taxe d’aménagement freinant la création d’activité",
      "title_en": "Reduce development tax that hinders business creation",
      "effect_source": "Gain pour les ménages — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Compensation collectivités; ciblage activités; systèmes fiscaux",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Économie / Collectivités",
      "legal_anchor": "Code impositions biens-services; finances locales; urbanisme",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNEN; collectivités; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Budget annuel",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Gain for households — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Compensation collectivités; ciblage activités; systèmes fiscaux",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Economy Ministry / Collectivités",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code impositions biens-services; finances locales; urbanisme",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; National Council for the Evaluation of Standards; local authorities; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annual budget cycle",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.06",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Simplification radicale des démarches entrepreneuriales",
      "title_en": "Radically simplify business procedures",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi d’habilitation + ordonnances ou loi de simplification",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets; guichet unique; interopérabilité; abrogations",
      "lead_authority": "Économie / Premier ministre / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Codes commerce, travail, fiscalité, sécurité sociale et environnement",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; entreprises; partenaires sociaux; CNIL; collectivités",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 36 mois",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Enabling Act and ordinance",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees; guichet unique; interopérabilité; abrogations",
      "lead_authority_en": "Economy Ministry / Prime Minister / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Codes commerce, travail, fiscalité, sécurité sociale and environnement",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; entreprises; partenaires sociaux; CNIL; local authorities",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 36 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.07",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Suppression des aides aux grandes entreprises sans contrepartie d’emploi",
      "title_en": "Remove aid to large companies without employment commitments",
      "effect_source": "Chiffrage détaillé dans la fiche correspondante",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances + loi ordinaire selon dispositifs",
      "secondary_instruments": "Révision conventions; clauses de remboursement; droit aides d’État",
      "lead_authority": "Économie / Budget / Travail",
      "legal_anchor": "Dispositifs nationaux; contrats; droit UE des aides d’État",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; entreprises; partenaires sociaux",
      "implementation_phase": "Revue dispositif par dispositif",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Detailed estimate in the relevant measure file",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act and Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Révision conventions; clauses of remboursement; droit aides d’État",
      "lead_authority_en": "Economy Ministry / Budget Ministry / Travail",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Dispositifs nationaux; contrats; droit UE of the aides d’État",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; entreprises; partenaires sociaux",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Revue dispositif par dispositif",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.08",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Conditionnalité stricte des aides industrielles",
      "title_en": "Apply strict conditions to industrial aid",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire ou lois financières",
      "secondary_instruments": "Conventions; indicateurs emploi/investissement; remboursement",
      "lead_authority": "Industrie / Budget / Travail",
      "legal_anchor": "Droit des aides d’État; contrats publics; lois financières",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; filières; partenaires sociaux",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 24 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.0",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Conventions; indicateurs emploi/investissement; remboursement",
      "lead_authority_en": "Industry Ministry / Budget Ministry / Travail",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Droit of the aides d’État; contrats publics; lois financières",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Commission européenne; filières; partenaires sociaux",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 24 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.09",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Engagement décennal de service en France des diplômés des grandes écoles",
      "title_en": "Ten-year service commitment in France for graduates of elite schools",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire à forte contrainte constitutionnelle et européenne",
      "secondary_instruments": "Contrats, compensation de formation, règles transitoires",
      "lead_authority": "Enseignement supérieur / Travail / Affaires européennes",
      "legal_anchor": "Liberté professionnelle; égalité; droit UE; contrats de formation",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; établissements; étudiants; Commission européenne",
      "implementation_phase": "Étude approfondie avant dépôt",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Contrats, compensation of formation, règles transitoires",
      "lead_authority_en": "Enseignement supérieur / Travail / Affaires européennes",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Liberté professionnelle; égalité; droit UE; contrats of formation",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; établissements; étudiants; Commission européenne",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Étude approfondie avant dépôt",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "8.10",
      "category": 8,
      "title_fr": "Récupération du manque à gagner sur les diplômés expatriés",
      "title_en": "Recovery of the public cost associated with expatriate graduates",
      "effect_source": "Recette non chiffrée — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire et convention fiscale selon le mécanisme",
      "secondary_instruments": "Assiette, recouvrement, conventions internationales, garanties",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Affaires étrangères / Enseignement supérieur",
      "legal_anchor": "Fiscalité; conventions internationales; libre circulation",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; partenaires internationaux",
      "implementation_phase": "Étude d’impact et compatibilité UE",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Unquantified revenue — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Assiette, recouvrement, conventions internationales, garanties",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Affaires étrangères / Enseignement supérieur",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Fiscalité; conventions internationales; libre circulation",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; partenaires internationaux",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Étude d’impact et compatibilité UE",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.01",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Architecture souveraine en 5 étages",
      "title_en": "Five-layer sovereign architecture",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation et doctrine interministérielle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Référentiels, marchés publics, architecture cible",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Numérique / ANSSI",
      "legal_anchor": "Droit numérique; commande publique; sécurité des systèmes",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; ANSSI; CNIL; ministères",
      "implementation_phase": "24 à 60 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Référentiels, marchés publics, architecture cible",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Digital Affairs / ANSSI",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Droit numérique; commande publique; sécurité of the systèmes",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; ANSSI; CNIL; ministries",
      "implementation_phase_en": "24 to 60 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.02",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Hébergement exclusif sur prestataires qualifiés SecNumCloud",
      "title_en": "Exclusive hosting with SecNumCloud-qualified providers",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Doctrine, marchés publics et textes sectoriels",
      "secondary_instruments": "Classification des données, clauses cloud, exceptions documentées",
      "lead_authority": "Numérique / ANSSI / ministères",
      "legal_anchor": "Doctrine cloud; commande publique; protection des données",
      "consultations": "ANSSI; CNIL; acheteurs; administrations",
      "implementation_phase": "Revue service par service",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Classification of the données, clauses cloud, exceptions documentées",
      "lead_authority_en": "Digital Affairs / ANSSI / ministères",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Doctrine cloud; commande publique; protection of the données",
      "consultations_en": "ANSSI; CNIL; acheteurs; administrations",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Revue service par service",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.03",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Plateforme d’inférence multi-modèles publique",
      "title_en": "Public multi-model inference platform",
      "effect_source": "Investissement — loi de programmation",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation et lois de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Établissement porteur, marchés, sécurité, gouvernance",
      "lead_authority": "Numérique / Recherche / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Droit public numérique; propriété intellectuelle; commande publique",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; ANSSI; chercheurs; acheteurs",
      "implementation_phase": "36 à 60 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment — programming act",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act and annual Finance Acts",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Établissement porteur, marchés, sécurité, gouvernance",
      "lead_authority_en": "Digital Affairs / Research Ministry / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Droit public numérique; propriété intellectuelle; commande publique",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; ANSSI; chercheurs; acheteurs",
      "implementation_phase_en": "36 to 60 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.04",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Clause de réversibilité contractuelle de 12 mois",
      "title_en": "Twelve-month contractual reversibility clause",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Modification des documents de marché et doctrine d’achat",
      "secondary_instruments": "CCAG/CCAP, plan de sortie, tests périodiques",
      "lead_authority": "Économie / Numérique / Acheteurs publics",
      "legal_anchor": "Code commande publique; CCAG-TIC",
      "consultations": "DAJ; acheteurs; ANSSI; fournisseurs",
      "implementation_phase": "Applicable aux nouveaux marchés",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "CCAG/CCAP, plan of sortie, tests périodiques",
      "lead_authority_en": "Economy Ministry / Digital Affairs / Acheteurs publics",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code commande publique; CCAG-TIC",
      "consultations_en": "DAJ; acheteurs; ANSSI; fournisseurs",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Applicable aux nouveaux marchés",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.05",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Formation des 5,85 millions d’agents publics, dont 2,58 millions dans la fonction publique de l’État sur 5 ans",
      "title_en": "Training of 5.85 million public employees over five years",
      "effect_source": "Coût de 3,2 milliards d’euros par an — investissement",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de programmation et lois de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Plans ministériels, marchés de formation, certification",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / Numérique / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général fonction publique; lois financières",
      "consultations": "Conseil commun fonction publique; syndicats; employeurs",
      "implementation_phase": "5 ans",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Cost of 3,2 billion euros per year — investissement",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Programming Act and annual Finance Acts",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Plans ministériels, training contracts, certification",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / Digital Affairs / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général fonction publique; lois financières",
      "consultations_en": "Common Council fonction publique; syndicats; employeurs",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Five years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.06",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Déploiement à la direction générale des finances publiques",
      "title_en": "Deployment at the public finance directorate",
      "effect_source": "15 à 25 milliards d’euros par an — recette estimée",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi de finances, cadre données et marchés publics",
      "secondary_instruments": "Expérimentations, contrôles, AIPD, recours",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / DGFiP / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Livre procédures fiscales; RGPD; règlement IA",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; organisations professionnelles",
      "implementation_phase": "Pilotes puis extension",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "15 to 25 billion euros per year — recette estimée",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Finance Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Expérimentations, contrôles, AIPD, recours",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / DGFiP / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Livre procédures fiscales; GDPR; règlement IA",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; organisations professionnelles",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Pilots followed by extension",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.07",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Automatisation de 521 000 postes administratifs, départs naturels",
      "title_en": "Automation of 521,000 administrative positions through natural attrition",
      "effect_source": "30 à 46 milliards d’euros par an — gain de productivité estimé",
      "primary_instrument": "Lois de programmation, finances et gestion RH",
      "secondary_instruments": "Dialogue social, mobilité, formation, systèmes numériques",
      "lead_authority": "Fonction publique / Budget / ministères",
      "legal_anchor": "Code général fonction publique; lois financières; droit social",
      "consultations": "Conseil commun fonction publique; syndicats; CNIL",
      "implementation_phase": "5 à 10 ans",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "30 to 46 billion euros per year — gain de productivité estimé",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Mixed legal instrument — detailed review required",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Dialogue social, mobilité, formation, systèmes numériques",
      "lead_authority_en": "Civil Service / Budget Ministry / ministères",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code général fonction publique; lois financières; droit social",
      "consultations_en": "Common Council fonction publique; syndicats; CNIL",
      "implementation_phase_en": "5 to 10 years",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.08",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Mission interministérielle rattachée au Premier ministre",
      "title_en": "Interministerial mission attached to the Prime Minister",
      "effect_source": "Investissement — loi de programmation",
      "primary_instrument": "Décret",
      "secondary_instruments": "Budget, compétences, gouvernance, rapport annuel",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 21; organisation gouvernementale",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État si décret en Conseil d’État; ministères",
      "implementation_phase": "Cent premiers jours",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Investment — programming act",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Budget, compétences, gouvernance, rapport annuel",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 21; organisation gouvernementale",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État if décret en Conseil d’État; ministries",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Cent premiers jours",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.09",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Contrôle parlementaire trimestriel des déploiements",
      "title_en": "Quarterly parliamentary oversight of deployments",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire ou règlements des assemblées selon le mécanisme",
      "secondary_instruments": "Rapports, auditions, accès aux informations protégées",
      "lead_authority": "Parlement / Gouvernement",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution; règlements assemblées; secrets protégés",
      "consultations": "Assemblées; Conseil d’État; autorités de contrôle",
      "implementation_phase": "12 à 18 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Rapports, auditions, accès to the informations protégées",
      "lead_authority_en": "Parliament / Gouvernement",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution; standing orders or regulations assemblées; secrets protégés",
      "consultations_en": "Assemblées; Conseil d’État; autorités of contrôle",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 to 18 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.10",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Audit annuel public de la Cour des comptes",
      "title_en": "Annual public audit by the Court of Auditors",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire ou dispositions financières",
      "secondary_instruments": "Mandat, données, calendrier, publication",
      "lead_authority": "Cour des comptes / Parlement",
      "legal_anchor": "Code juridictions financières; lois financières",
      "consultations": "Cour des comptes; Conseil d’État; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Annuel",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Mandat, données, calendrier, publication",
      "lead_authority_en": "Court of Audit / Parliament",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code juridictions financières; lois financières",
      "consultations_en": "Cour of the comptes; Conseil d’État; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Annuel",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.11",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Indicateurs trimestriels publiés au Journal officiel",
      "title_en": "Quarterly indicators published in the Official Journal",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — contrôle démocratique",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire et arrêté de définition",
      "secondary_instruments": "Définitions, périmètres, format ouvert, contrôle qualité",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Droit de la publication; données publiques",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; services statistiques; CNIL",
      "implementation_phase": "12 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — democratic oversight",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and order",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Définitions, scopes, format ouvert, contrôle qualité",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Droit of the publication; données publiques",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; services statistiques; CNIL",
      "implementation_phase_en": "12 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.12",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Intervention humaine obligatoire pour toute décision défavorable",
      "title_en": "Mandatory human intervention for every adverse decision",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — garantie juridique",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire et textes sectoriels",
      "secondary_instruments": "Procédures, information, recours, journalisation",
      "lead_authority": "Justice / Numérique / ministères",
      "legal_anchor": "Règlement IA; RGPD; codes sectoriels",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; autorités indépendantes",
      "implementation_phase": "Avant déploiement",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — legal safeguard",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Procédures, information, recours, journalisation",
      "lead_authority_en": "Justice Ministry / Digital Affairs / ministères",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Règlement IA; GDPR; codes sectoriels",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; autorités indépendantes",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Avant déploiement",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.13",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Plateforme publique de transparence",
      "title_en": "Public transparency platform",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — contrôle démocratique",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire et décret",
      "secondary_instruments": "Données publiables, secrets, formats, mises à jour",
      "lead_authority": "Premier ministre / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "CRPA; protection données; secrets protégés",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; administrations",
      "implementation_phase": "18 à 30 mois",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — democratic oversight",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act and decree",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Données publiables, secrets, formats, mises à jour",
      "lead_authority_en": "Prime Minister / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: CRPA; protection données; secrets protégés",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; administrations",
      "implementation_phase_en": "18 to 30 months",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "9.14",
      "category": 9,
      "title_fr": "Contrôle préventif des marchés publics par détection d’anomalies",
      "title_en": "Preventive anomaly detection in public procurement",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — mesure normative",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi ordinaire, règlement et marchés publics",
      "secondary_instruments": "Données, seuils, contrôle humain, recours",
      "lead_authority": "Économie / Budget / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Code commande publique; RGPD; règlement IA",
      "consultations": "DAJ; CNIL; acheteurs; entreprises",
      "implementation_phase": "Pilotes puis extension",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — regulatory measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Ordinary Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Données, seuils, contrôle humain, recours",
      "lead_authority_en": "Economy Ministry / Budget Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Code commande publique; GDPR; règlement IA",
      "consultations_en": "DAJ; CNIL; acheteurs; entreprises",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Pilots followed by extension",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.01",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Constitutionnalisation de l’équilibre budgétaire, modèle allemand",
      "title_en": "Constitutional balanced-budget rule inspired by Germany",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique d’application, clauses de crise",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Premier ministre / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 34 et 89; droit UE budgétaire",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act d’application, clauses of crise",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Prime Minister / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 34 and 89; droit UE budgétaire",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.02",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Frein à l’endettement référendaire, modèle suisse",
      "title_en": "Referendum-based debt brake inspired by Switzerland",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique, mécanisme référendaire, exceptions",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Premier ministre / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 11 et 89; lois financières",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act, mécanisme référendaire, exceptions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Prime Minister / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 11 and 89; lois financières",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.03",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Plafond constitutionnel de déficit structurel à 0,35 pour cent du PIB",
      "title_en": "Constitutional structural-deficit ceiling of 0.35% of GDP",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique de calcul et correction",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution; droit UE; méthodologie solde structurel",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; HCFP; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act of calcul and correction",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution; droit UE; méthodologie solde structurel",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; HCFP; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.04",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Mécanisme automatique de gel de crédits en cas de dérapage",
      "title_en": "Automatic appropriation freeze when targets are missed",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — effet institutionnel",
      "primary_instrument": "Loi organique relative aux lois de finances",
      "secondary_instruments": "Décrets d’avance/annulation, clauses de sauvegarde",
      "lead_authority": "Budget / Premier ministre",
      "legal_anchor": "LOLF; Constitution art. 47",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; HCFP; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Après réforme organique",
      "confidence": "B",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — institutional effect",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Organic Act",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "decrees d’avance/annulation, clauses of sauvegarde",
      "lead_authority_en": "Budget Ministry / Prime Minister",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Organic Budget Act (LOLF); Constitution art. 47",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; HCFP; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Après réforme organique",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.05",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Révision constitutionnelle 1, réduction parlementaire",
      "title_en": "Constitutional amendment 1, smaller Parliament",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Lois organiques et électorales",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Parlement / Justice",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 24, 25 et 89",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Lois organiques and électorales",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Parliament / Justice Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 24, 25 and 89",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.06",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Révision constitutionnelle 2, équilibre budgétaire",
      "title_en": "Constitutional amendment 2, budget balance",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique et lois financières",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 34, 47 et 89",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act and lois financières",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 34, 47 and 89",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.07",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Révision constitutionnelle 3, intelligence artificielle",
      "title_en": "Constitutional amendment 3, artificial intelligence",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle à justifier précisément",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique ou ordinaire selon les garanties",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Justice / Numérique",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution; Charte droits fondamentaux UE",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; CNIL; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Étude constitutionnelle préalable",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act or ordinaire depending on les garanties",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Justice Ministry / Digital Affairs",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution; Charte droits fondamentaux UE",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; CNIL; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Étude constitutionnelle préalable",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.08",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Révision constitutionnelle 4, transparence des rémunérations",
      "title_en": "Constitutional amendment 4, pay transparency",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle ou loi selon périmètre",
      "secondary_instruments": "Protection données, exceptions et publication",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Fonction publique",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution; RGPD; vie privée; transparence",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Parlement",
      "implementation_phase": "Arbitrage du niveau normatif",
      "confidence": "C",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Protection données, exceptions and publication",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Civil Service",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution; GDPR; vie privée; transparence",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; CNIL; Parliament",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Arbitrage du niveau normatif",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "10.09",
      "category": 10,
      "title_fr": "Révision constitutionnelle 5, plafonnement des prélèvements",
      "title_en": "Constitutional amendment 5, cap on compulsory levies",
      "effect_source": "Effet structurel — Constitution",
      "primary_instrument": "Révision constitutionnelle",
      "secondary_instruments": "Loi organique de calcul, périmètre et exceptions",
      "lead_authority": "Présidence / Budget",
      "legal_anchor": "Constitution art. 34 et 89; droit UE",
      "consultations": "Conseil d’État; Parlement; Conseil constitutionnel",
      "implementation_phase": "Phase constitutionnelle",
      "confidence": "A",
      "status": "Qualification juridique initiale à expertiser",
      "source_scope": "Titre et effet repris du Plan de Rupture; qualification juridique ajoutée en V20.8.1",
      "effect_source_en": "Structural effect — constitutional measure",
      "primary_instrument_en": "Constitutional amendment",
      "secondary_instruments_en": "Organic Act of calcul, scope and exceptions",
      "lead_authority_en": "Presidency / Budget Ministry",
      "legal_anchor_en": "French legal anchors: Constitution art. 34 and 89; droit UE",
      "consultations_en": "Conseil d’État; Parliament; Constitutional Council",
      "implementation_phase_en": "Constitutional phase",
      "status_en": "Initial legal classification requiring expert review",
      "source_scope_en": "Title and stated effect preserved from the Plan de Rupture; legal classification added by the website project."
    }
  ]
}